
Living in Shelter Island, NY
Community in Suffolk County, New York · population 2,125Updated November 2026
- Homes 142% above New York
- Incomes 93% above New York
- Low violent crime
- High disaster risk
- Patchy home internet
Shelter Island in New York
Shelter Island, New York, is a town of 2,125 people that suits high-income households who can afford high home prices. The median household income is about $165,700, 93% above the state average, while the median home value is about $1,025,400, 142% above it. The average commute of 41 minutes is 26% longer than the state average, so it may not suit people who need short commutes.
Summary written by AI from the official figures on this page only.
Shelter Island in New York
Key numbers
Pros and cons of living in Shelter Island
Pros
- Household incomes are 93% above the New York median
- Low violent crime: 1.2 per 1,000 people (US 3.3)
- Mild summers: July highs average 81°F
Cons
- Homes cost 142% more than the New York median ($1,025,400)
- Long commutes: 41 minutes on average
- FEMA rates the county's natural hazard risk relatively high
- Only 48% of households have broadband
Worked out from the figures below, compared with New York and the US.
Cost of living in Shelter Island
| Figure | Shelter Island | New York | US |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical home valueZillow, October 2026 | $1,859,412 | — | — |
| Median home valueCensus ACS 2020-2024 | $1,025,400 | $423,800 | $332,700 |
| Median household income (a year)Census ACS 2020-2024 | $165,734 | $85,974 | $80,734 |
| Typical property tax (a year)Census ACS 2020-2024 | $4,174 | $6,582 | $3,119 |
Is Shelter Island safe?
Shelter Island had 1.2 violent crimes and 5.4 property crimes per 1,000 people in 2025, against 3.3 and 15.5 across the US. Crime rates in small places and places with many visitors can look high because they're counted per resident.
| Figure | Shelter Island | New York | US |
|---|---|---|---|
| Violent crimes per 1,000 peopleFBI, 2025 | 1.2 | 3.7 | 3.3 |
| Property crimes per 1,000 peopleFBI, 2025 | 5.4 | 15.7 | 15.5 |
Weather in Shelter Island
| Figure | Shelter Island |
|---|---|
| January average lowNOAA 1991–2020, Bridgehampton, NY station | 23°F |
| July average highNOAA 1991–2020, Bridgehampton, NY station | 81°F |
| Rain and snow (water) a yearNOAA 1991–2020, Bridgehampton, NY station | 50 inches |
Schools and education in Shelter Island
| Figure | Shelter Island | New York | US |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public schools in townNCES, 2024-25 | 1 | — | — |
| Adults 25+ with a bachelor's degreeCensus ACS 2020-2024 | 56.0% | 40.2% | 35.7% |
| Median age (years)Census ACS 2020-2024 | 41.3 | 39.8 | 38.9 |
We count public schools by address; we don't rate them.
Hidden costs and risks
The typical property tax bill is $4,174 a year (about 0.41% of the median home value), compared with 1.55% across New York and 0.94% across the US.
FEMA rates Suffolk County's overall natural hazard risk as relatively high, with the highest ratings for coastal flooding, flooding and hurricane. Home insurance often costs more where flood, storm or wildfire risk is high, so get a quote before you buy.
- Overall riskRelatively High
- FloodingRelatively High
- Coastal floodingVery High
- HurricaneRelatively High
- TornadoRelatively Moderate
- WildfireRelatively Low
- Heat waveRelatively Moderate
Ratings are for the whole county, compared with every other US county. “Not rated” means FEMA found no meaningful risk or had too little data.
Daily life
- Home internet48% of households have broadbandNew York 91%, US 91%. Counts subscriptions, not speeds.
- Nearest big cityNew York, NY: 90 milesAbout 2.5 hours by car (rough estimate)
- Commute41 minutes on average, one wayNew York 33 min, US 26 min (Census ACS 2020-2024)
- Nearest airport with flightsWesterly State Airport (WST): 33 milesAbout 65 minutes by car (rough estimate)
Distances are straight lines from the town center; drive times are rough estimates, not route directions.
Ask about Shelter Island
Answers come only from the official figures on this page.
Written by AI; numbers are checked against the data. 5 questions a day. Questions are saved, without your name, so we can see what people want to know. Please don't include personal details.
Similar towns nearby
More towns in Suffolk County
West Babylon · Coram · Central Islip · Commack · Huntington Station · Centereach · Bay Shore · Shirley · Deer Park · Lindenhurst · West Islip · Holbrook · all 135 towns